US Hypocrisy on Support of Regimes Using Child Soldiers
October 5, 2013
Jason Ditz / AntiWar.com & Al Jazeera & Reuters
The US has imposed sanctions on Syria, Sudan, Myanmar, the Central African Republic and Rwanda – countries that utilize child soldiers. At the same time, the Obama Administration has issued 100% blanket waivers to Yemen, Chad and South Sudan, and partial waivers to Somalia and the Democratic Republic of Congo -- invoking "national security" to keep the aid flowing to some of the world's worst human rights violators.
US Grants Child Soldier 'Waivers' to Allies to Bypass Sanctions
Jason Ditz / AntiWar.com
(October 3, 2013) -- The United States did its annual child soldier assessment abroad, imposing sanctions on Syria, Sudan, Myanmar, the Central African Republic and Rwanda. Only Rwanda was actually receiving significant aid in the first place, though CAR also was before the recent regime change.
The list of nations where child soldiers are used is a lot longer than that, of course, but the Obama Administration has issued waivers for the rest, including 100% blanket waivers to Yemen, Chad and South Sudan, and partial waivers to Somalia and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
The Child Soldiers Prevention Act of 2008 (CPSA) forbids the US from providing military aid to governments or militias that recruit and use child soldiers, but allows the president to override the ban in special cases on “national security” grounds.
Since the law came into effect, President Obama has regularly taken advantage of that waiver to keep the aid flowing to some of the worst human rights violators in the world.
US Sanctions Rwanda, Others Over Child Soldiers
Al Jazeera America
(October 4, 2013) -- The United States has moved to halt its military aid to Rwanda because of the country's support for M23, a rebel group believed to use child soldiers in the neighboring Democratic Republic of the Congo, the State Department said. But some countries with child soldiers in their own militaries were exempt from the sanctions, and human rights activists say this sends a mixed message.
The action on Rwanda is part of US sanctions targeting the use of child soldiers that also apply to the Central African Republic, Myanmar, Sudan and Syria, the State Department said Thursday. It was not immediately clear whether those nations receive US military assistance.
"Our goal is to work with countries who have been listed to ensure that any involvement in child soldiers -- any involvement in the recruitment of child soldiers -- stop," said US Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs Linda Thomas-Greenfield.
State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf said Rwanda was sanctioned because of its "support for the M23, a rebel group which continues to actively recruit and abduct children" and to threaten the stability of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
However, three other countries whose militaries are known to recruit and use child soldiers -- Chad, South Sudan and Yemen -- received waivers from the US sanctions, another State Department official said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
The Democratic Republic of the Congo and Somalia received partial waivers, the official said, adding that the Obama administration has decided such exemptions "would be in the national interest of the United States."
Human rights activists are concerned that the partial waivers and exemptions send an inconsistent message.
"When some countries continue to get military assistance even while they continue to use child soldiers, it gives those countries little incentive to change their practices. We have consistently pushed the administration to apply at least partial sanctions on governments that continue to recruit and use child soldiers, including Chad, Yemen and South Sudan," Jo Becker, children's rights advocacy director at Human Rights Watch, told Al Jazeera.
"We have seen real progress and welcome the move to withhold assistance from Rwanda, CAR, and partial assistance from DRC and Somalia," she said. "This is a real improvement and shows that the US is willing to use its leverage to help end the use of child soldiers. However, it is still letting too many countries off the hook."
By law, the US State Department, as part of its annual report on human trafficking, must keep track of nations whose governments recruit and use children as soldiers. The 10 countries affected by Thursday's actions were all cited in the State Department's latest findings, issued in June.
Rwanda will not receive US International Military Education and Training funds, which help train foreign militaries, nor will it get US Foreign Military Financing, which funds the sale of US military material and services, Harf said.
Brig. Gen. Joseph Nzabamwita, spokesman for the Rwanda Defense Forces, said his country should not be held responsible for events outside its control.
"It is surprising that Rwanda would be liable for matters that are neither on its territory nor in its practices," he said. "As a long-term partner of the Rwanda Defense Forces, the United States has ample evidence that our forces have never tolerated the use of children in combat.
"Rwanda's commitment to a sustainable solution that seeks to bring an end to the DRC conflict and its consequences, including the use of child soldiers, remains unchanged," he said.
"The collaboration between the government of Rwanda and the United States remains strong, particularly in the field of peacekeeping, and Rwanda will continue to hold its forces to the highest standards of professionalism and discipline," he added.
Harf said she was not aware that Syria was receiving any US military assistance. She also said she did not believe Myanmar receives such aid, and would check on whether Sudan did.
Those countries can be denied some types of US funds for military assistance unless the White House grants a waiver. A 2008 law also allows US officials to block licenses needed for those nations to buy military equipment.
It was not immediately clear how much US funding would be blocked because of Thursday's action.
M23 is a Tutsi-dominated rebel group of former Congolese soldiers that began taking over parts of eastern Congo last year, accusing the government of failing to honor a 2009 peace deal.
United Nations investigators and the Congolese government have accused Rwanda of sponsoring the rebellion, a charge Rwanda denies.
"Any support of those rebel groups is seen as contributing to conflict in the region," Thomas-Greenfield told reporters, adding that US officials will continue to discuss the issue with the Rwandan government.
The United States will still support peacekeeping efforts in Rwanda, the other official added.
Al Jazeera and Reuters. Amel Ahmed contributed to this report.
Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.