Palestinians Say Israel Caused their Summer Water Shortage
June 28, 2016
Mohammed Daraghmeh and Daniella Cheslow / Big Story & Alex Traiman/ Jewish and Israel News
As Palestinians in the West Bank fast from dawn to dusk in scorching heat during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, tens of thousands of people have been affected by a drought that has greatly reduced the flow to their taps. Israel admits it's been forced to cut water supplies to the parched area, saying that nearby Jewish settlements have also been affected. But Palestinian areas appear to have been hit much harder, and both sides are blaming each other.
Palestinians Say Israel Caused their Summer Water Shortage
Mohammed Daraghmeh and Daniella Cheslow / Big Story
June 28, 2016) -- SALEM, West Bank (AP) -- As Palestinians in the West Bank fast from dawn to dusk in scorching heat during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, tens of thousands of people have been affected by a drought that has greatly reduced the flow to their taps.
Israel admits it's been forced to cut water supplies to the parched area, saying that nearby Jewish settlements have also been affected. But Palestinian areas appear to have been hit much harder, and both sides are blaming each other.
The water shortage has harmed farmers, forced people to bathe less and created a booming business for tanker trucks that deliver water.
Israel blames it on the unusually early summer heat and the Palestinians' refusal to cooperate with Israel on renovating their leaky pipe system. Palestinians say the shortage is evidence of the uneven distribution of water from an underground aquifer -- which was enshrined in an outdated peace agreement.
The shortages come as Israel has made great strides toward water independence through a fast-growing desalinization program, which today provides about 30 percent of Israel's water and has reduced the country's dependency on meek rivers and sparse rainfall.
But the Palestinian villages in the West Bank and some isolated Israeli settlements are not connected to the national water grid, relying instead on local underground supplies.
Israeli environmental advocate Gidon Bromberg says the water shortage is "outrageous."
"The fact there is excess water in Israel means for very first time, the natural water can be shared at low cost to Israel and high gain to Palestinians and Israelis together," said Bromberg, the director of EcoPeace Middle East, a group that promotes region-wide environmental cooperation.
In Salem, a village of 7,000 people in the northern West Bank, Israel has slowed the water flow by two-thirds for a month now, said local water engineer Wahed Hamdan. What remains is further diminished by a leaky pipe system installed in 1982, he said.
To cope with the diminished flow, Salem has instituted a rotation regime between neighborhoods, Hamdan said. Residents use pumps to bring the trickle to storage tanks on their roofs but the weak stream cannot reach homes on the outskirts of the village.
When the water runs out, Mohammed Fahmi, 22, does a brisk trade supplying the village homes via 800-gallon (3,000-liter) tankers, which he delivers for about $20 per truck -- which can quadruple a family's monthly water bill.
The water comes from wells drilled by the Palestinian Authority. But there's often not enough for everyone. "Some people wait two days until I can deliver," Fahmi said.
Suleiman Hasan, a driver from Salem, said he is showering less to save water. His garden has dried up, and his olive tree has turned yellow.
By contrast, in the West Bank's political center of Ramallah, water is delivered twice a week, and the pressure is high enough to reach rooftop storage tanks without extra pumping. Usually, supplies last until the next delivery.
The problems with the current system of water distribution in the West Bank are rooted in the 1967 Mideast war, when Israel conquered the territory from Jordan and took control of the Mountain Aquifer. The aquifer straddles the frontier between the West Bank and Israel and is a major source of water to both sides.
Under interim peace accords signed in 1995, Israel controls 80 percent of the aquifer while the Palestinian Authority is allocated 20 percent. Israel also draws water from the Sea of Galilee and from desalinization, sources that are not available to the Palestinians. Israel is required by the peace accords to sell additional water to the Palestinians.
The Oslo Accords, which divided up the natural water resources, were intended to last for five years, pending a final peace agreement. But they remain in effect after two decades of failed peace efforts.
Israel Water Authority spokesman Uri Schor said Israel sells the Palestinians 64 million cubic meters of water each year, double the amount stipulated in the 1995 accords. He said that to protect the groundwater, Israel has reduced supplies to both Palestinian and Israeli communities in the West Bank, without providing exact figures.
Schor accused the Palestinians of refusing to convene the Joint Water Committee, a body established by the Oslo Accords to manage the shared water resources. Without the committee, Schor says, it's impossible to approve repairs to infrastructure -- and damaged pipes can drain away up to a third of supplies.
"The Palestinians are taking advantage of this to say Israel is taking our water," he said. "This is rubbish. The area has a problem and this can be solved by upgrading all the infrastructure, but the Palestinians veto this."
Palestinian Water Authority director Mazen Ghoneim said the joint committee has not met in five years because Israelis use it to force Palestinians to approve water projects for Israeli settlements, which the Palestinians and most of the international community consider illegal.
Ghoneim demanded a renegotiation of the 80-20 ratio of water sharing in the West Bank and alleged that the Palestinian share has actually declined due to the increased population and worsening leakage. He said villages and cities that are home to some 120,000 Palestinians have been affected.
Israeli and Palestinian leaders have not been willing to renegotiate water access without a larger peace deal -- which seems highly unlikely, at least in the near future.
In the meantime, foreign governments have attempted to help the Palestinians improve their water network. Since 2000, the American government's USAID has spent tens of millions of dollars upgrading some 600 miles (900 kilometers) of pipelines, mostly in the West Bank.
Water shortages have hit Israeli settlements as well, although to a lesser degree.
Esther Allouch, spokeswoman for the Samaria Regional Council, a group of settlements in the northern West Bank, said the hilltop settlement of Tapuah, with a population of 1,000, had a three-day shortage recently and also needed to bring in water tankers, which her council pays for.
Over the weekend, nearly all the 20,000 residents of the Israeli city of Ariel in the West Bank experienced a half-hour water interruption. Allouch said settlements are suspending irrigation of farmland and reducing their use of dishwashers and showers.
"For years we have been saying that the infrastructure in Judea and Samaria is not sufficient," she said, using the biblical name for the West Bank.
Bromberg, the environmental advocate, said the problem could be solved by renegotiating water allocation and allowing the Palestinians to drill more groundwater. He said Palestinians get roughly 70 liters of water per person per day, while Israelis get more than twice that amount.
"Holding the Palestinian public hostage to Oslo (accords) means they are not getting a fair share of the natural water," he said.
Cheslow reported from Jerusalem. Follow Mohammed Daraghmeh on Twitter at www.twitter.com/MohammedDaragh1 and Daniella Cheslow at www.twitter.com/dacheslow
Palestinian Water Shortages and Israel's
Water Supply: Behind the Headlines
Alex Traiman/ Jewish and Israel News (JNS.org)
(July 1, 2016) -- Highly publicized severe water shortages in Palestinian villages in the northern West Bank have caused tens of thousands of local residents to suffer without an adequate water supply, bringing negative attention to Israel in international media.
For instance, a recent Associated Press news headline -- "Palestinians say Israel caused their summer water shortage" -- was republished by mainstream media such as ABC News and the San Francisco Chronicle.
The current situation has been caused by a number of factors relating to Israeli-Palestinian water policy, damaged infrastructure, and an extended heat wave. Yet the shortages -- which also affect neighboring Israeli villages, albeit to a much lesser extent -- are raising serious questions about the overall state of Israel's water supply, water policy, and a crumbling water infrastructure that was never designed to serve so many residents.
"What has been happening over the last few weeks is a combination of problems," said Dr. Saul Arlosoroff, former director of Mekorot, Israel's national water company. "Number one, a critical pipe bursting; number two, the [regional water supply] network cannot supply the demand; and thirdly, water in this area is prioritized toward Israelis over Palestinians."
Arlosoroff explained that the water carrier in the West Bank is broken into subsystems. In this area, Israelis and Palestinians get their water from the same subsystem.
"Today we are talking about a specific subsystem in Nablus. Tomorrow we could be talking about water supply across the entire West Bank," Arlosoroff told JNS.org.
Much of the water infrastructure for Israelis and Palestinians in this region was laid down more than 40 years ago, and it is now "coming to the end of its expected lifecycle," according to Arlosoroff.
"We did not think that the pipes that were laid in the 1970's in the West Bank would be used for such a long period of time," he said.
In addition, increased water demand by growing Israeli and Palestinian populations is also stretching the limits of the infrastructure's intended capabilities. "The quality of the pipes and the diameters are inadequate," said Arlosoroff. "The diameter that was used for the pipes was much smaller than what is required for the size of the population that there is right now."
The current situation is "undoubtedly a strong warning" for what Israel is going to face in the near future, Arlosoroff argued.
"In the next five, 10, or 15 years, the entire network will not work anymore," he said. "We're talking about a higher consumption of water and the network was simply not built for that….It's not just the subsystems. The entire network will need to be enhanced."
Yet once such a project is started, it could take many years to fix or replace the water infrastructure -- at a significant cost.
"Each piece of pipe in a mountainous, rocky, limestone area could cost millions. It's very difficult to know the precise cost, but if the entire network in the West Bank will need to be replaced, it could cost hundreds of millions of dollars," said Arlosoroff.
As for the current water shortages, most acutely felt in the Palestinian village of Sulfite, political issues between Israeli and Palestinian authorities have prevented broken infrastructure from being repaired in a timely fashion. While Israel runs the national water carrier that supplies water to both Israelis and Palestinians, Palestinians have full administrative control over most Palestinian villages, and fixing the infrastructure requires bilateral cooperation.
"There is a joint water committee that is supposed to meet every few months, to discuss water issues and to solve problems. But currently the committee is not meeting," said Nadav Tal, a hydrologist at EcoPeace, a not-for-profit organization with offices in Tel Aviv, Bethlehem and the Jordanian capital of Amman that is dedicated to promoting solutions for regional water issues.
"We urge the committee to meet as soon as possible," Tal told JNS.org.
Israel has three natural water sources: Lake Kinneret (the Sea of Galilee) and two underground aquifers. The 1993 Oslo Accords allotted Israel approximately 80 percent of the water that comes from the mountain aquifer, which runs under much of the West Bank, while Palestinians were allotted approximately 20 percent. The allotments did not account for growing demand for water in the region.
Yet according to Tal, "the issue is much larger than just an issue of water shortages" and allocations. Due to the lack of water supply, Palestinians have dug a series of illegal wells to draw additional water from the aquifer, further dwindling supply.
"In addition to the issues of water shortage, we are also seeing tremendous issues of pollution, both in Palestinian and Israeli territories. There is significant pollution to the mountain aquifer, as well as to rivers which flow through Israeli territory toward the Mediterranean," said Tal.
Tal said that Israelis and Palestinians alike have been reluctant to work on an agreement that can help solve the complex water situation between the two populations.
"We believe that the water issue is an issue that can be solved, even in absence of any kind of full peace agreement," he said.
Palestinians in particular, said Tal, "have been reluctant to sign any water arrangement" because they prefer to negotiate in a wider political context.
"I am sure that local Palestinians would prefer that their government sign a deal to solve local water issues," he said.
For Israel, a country that is no stranger to image problems, the inability to solve the ongoing water shortage creates yet another public relations challenge.
"Undoubtedly, the continuation of this problem can erode the image that the international community has of Israel," said Arlosoroff.
In recent years, Israeli desalination plants have increased Israel's water supply and were intended to solve water shortages in the long run. But below-average rainfall during the past few years -- particularly in northern Israel near Lake Kinneret, Israel's largest fresh water source -- has created additional water shortages.
"We thought that our problems were over and that it would take a long time before scarcity would be part of our water sector, as it was in the past," Arlosoroff said. "Everybody thought that for years and years the issue of water would not be in the media. If the droughts will continue, Israel can find itself in a severe water shortage despite the desalination plants."
Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.