Unarmed Americans Die by Police Bullets but Attorney General Lynch Still Does Nothing
July 9, 2016 Marc Ash / Reader Supported News
Commentary: You said: "All of us as Americans should be troubled by the shootings." All of us are. Attorney General Lynch is the best-positioned person in the nation to confront excessive police violence. As the head of the Department of Justice she has more powerful tools at her disposal than any other law enforcement officer in the nation. But she will not use the power that she has.
Americans Are Troubled, Mr. President,
But Attorney General Lynch Still Does Nothing Marc Ash / Reader Supported News
WASHINGTON (July 8, 2016) -- You said: "All of us as Americans should be troubled by the shootings."
All of us are. To make matters worse, 12 police officers have apparently been shot in Dallas at a demonstration to protest the shootings. Reportedly five of them are dead.
Attorney General Lynch is the best-positioned person in the nation to confront excessive police violence. As the head of the Department of Justice she has more powerful tools at her disposal than any other law enforcement officer in the nation. But she will not use the power that she has.
Instead, she and Vanita Gupta, who heads the department's Civil Rights Division, launch investigation after investigation for political cover, always deciding in the end not to proceed with charges.
Yes, for the record, Civil Rights charges in many of these cases can be brought. Most recently in the case of black Chicago police officer Aldo Brown. Brown was in fact charged and convicted on Civil Rights charges for beating a suspect armed with a gun, in violation of the constitution.
So it can be done. Neither of your Attorney General appointees however has ever chosen to do it. So here we are in the middle of a bloodbath that can only be mitigated by justice. Not justice for some, but justice for all.
You also said, "We have extraordinary appreciation and respect for the vast majority of police officers." Would you like to have less respect for American police officers? Watch the video below. I guarantee you will never respect a police officer again.
Valerie Castile, the mother of Philando Castile, the man killed by police as he sat in his car, said it plainly, "We're being hunted, every day. It's a silent war against African-American people as a whole." To separate police officers shot from people shot by police officers expands the conflict. To end the conflict, there must be justice for all.
I've said it before, most recently in January of this year, you and Attorney General Lynch must act. [See full article below -- EAW] Until you do that, the violence is going to continue to escalate. This is a problem that cannot be solved at a podium. It must be confronted with federal authority when local jurisdictions cannot or will not act. You must.
(January 5, 2016) -- I Without any doubt, the crisis of police use of force, often lethal, against the communities they serve in the United States of America has reached an unprecedented and unacceptable level.
While the killings of people confronted by law enforcement officers continue at record levels, the tenure of the Obama administration has been marked by compassion, but it has also been marked by nearly total inaction.
The Justice Department, under the guidance of then-incoming attorney general Loretta Lynch, in fact stated as an objective greater cooperation with police departments, with no apparent plan whatsoever to confront police killings raging across the nation.
Officially, Attorney General Lynch hasn't even recognized that a problem exists. As it stands now, it is the position of the attorney general that local and state police agencies should not even be required to keep statistics on the number of people they kill.
It is left to independent reporting to tabulate the staggering numbers. The Guardian's running count of people killed by police is called The Counted. They list 1,136 people killed by US police in 2015. Also quite helpful are the efforts of a small organization, KilledByPolice.net. They put the number of those killed by police in 2015 at 1,200.
Former attorney general Eric Holder was at least willing to litigate Consent Decrees mandating a few reforms at some departments. However no action was ever filed against any officer for any killing, regardless of the circumstances. Litigation cannot stop a bullet. When the killers go uncharged and unpunished, the killings continue.
The circumstances in many of the cases not only rose to the level of establishing probable cause, they often portrayed conduct on the part of the officers involved that was so brazen as to demand justice. But justice from the Department of Justice was never forthcoming.
The killing of 12-year-old Tamir Rice by Cleveland police officer Timothy Loehmann was a stark example of the human cost, the suffering caused by police officers empowered to use lethal force with virtual immunity from prosecution.
The shocking video of Loehmann gunning down a child is just the first piece of evidence in a case that demands action. After shooting the 12-year-old, Loehmann falsified his report to investigators, telling them that he had instructed the child several times to drop the pellet gun he was holding. Loehmann was lying. He simply jumped out of the patrol car and gunned the boy down. No warning, no protocol – just two bullets.
The presence of a pellet gun in Tamir's possession is used to justify his killing. A completely false premise. In fact, carrying an unconcealed firearm publicly in Ohio is completely legal. A choice made by the voters of that state.
It's not surprising. One of Loehmann's firearms training instructors was so concerned about Loehmann's instability that he literally confiscated Loehmann's guns during a training exercise.
The training instructor, Deputy Chief Jim Polak of the Independence Police Department, described an "emotional meltdown, dangerous loss of composure, dismal handgun performance."
Polak concluded, "Individually, these events would not be considered major situations but, when taken together, they show a pattern of a lack of maturity, indiscretion, and not following instructions . . . I do not believe time nor training will be able to change or correct these deficiencies."
Clearly there was a threat to public safety at the Cudell Recreation Center on November 22nd, 2014, but it was Police Officer Timothy Loehmann, not Tamir Rice. Tamir just paid the price.
The prosecutor, Timothy J. McGinty, was free to do or say anything he wanted with the Grand Jury convened in the case, and no one is ever allowed to know what that was. There is zero accountability, and as a result zero credibility there. None.
When state and local authorities will not prosecute local police, the last recourse for victims is the United States Department of Justice. You know well that this is your sworn duty.
The inaction of the Obama administration and the Justice Department can only embolden men like Timothy Loehmann. The message is: "Regardless of the facts, federal law enforcement will not intervene." In fact, throughout the entire Obama tenure that has absolutely been the case.
Saudi Arabia has come under sharp attack for executing 47 prisoners this week, raising the number executed over the past year, by some estimates, to as high as 200. That number, however disturbing, pales in comparison to the staggering, appalling number of people killed in America by police.
This is by every measure an immediate crisis. These senseless killings under color of law cause great harm and suffering at home and a devastating loss of credibility before the world.
It is imperative. You must act.
Marc Ash is the founder and former Executive Director of Truthout, and is now founder and Editor of Reader Supported News.