Ramadi Falls as US-trained Troops Flee, Leaving US-made Tanks and Weapons for ISIS
May 20, 2015
Jason Ditz / AntiWar.com & Robert Burns / Associated Press Writer
Once again, the Pentagon's costly program of "arming and training" foreign troops has proven to be a failure. As has happened previously in Iraq, cities once considered secure have fallen to ISIS militants. Once again, Iraqi troops threw down their arms and fled, abandoning dozens of US military vehicles, including tanks, armored personnel carriers and artillery pieces, leaving the city and the trove of US weapons to the forces of ISIS.
Iraqi Troops Abandon
US-Made Tanks, Artillery to ISIS in Ramadi Loss
Jason Ditz / AntiWar.com
(May 19, 2015) -- When ISIS took the Iraqi city of Mosul last year, they seized an army’s worth of US-made weaponry and vehicles. The US air war against ISIS over the last nine months has centered in great measure on destroying that gear, while ferrying new gear to the Iraqi military.
Then Ramadi fell over the weekend, and it’s Mosul all over again. Despite the US downplaying the significance of the loss, the Pentagon is confirming that half a dozen tanks and significant artillery and armored vehicles, along with other gear, were abandoned by Iraqi troops fleeing the Anbar capital.
With the news, the Pentagon is also stepping back from its predictions of retaking Ramadi in a matter of days, saying it “will be difficult,” and insisting that they’re sticking to their existing strategy.
It also puts a different spin on Iraq rushing more tanks to the Ramadi line to try to take the city back, with the risk that these tanks too will eventually be abandoned to ISIS.
Iraqis Abandoned US-Supplied Equipment in Ramadi
Robert Burns / Associated Press
WASHINGTON (May 19, 2015) -- Iraqi troops abandoned dozens of US military vehicles, including tanks, armored personnel carriers and artillery pieces when they fled Islamic State fighters in Ramadi on Sunday, the Pentagon said Tuesday.
A Pentagon spokesman, Col. Steve Warren, estimated that a half dozen tanks were abandoned, a similar number of artillery pieces, a larger number of armored personnel carriers and about 100 wheeled vehicles like Humvees. He said some of the vehicles were in working condition; others were not because they had not been moved for months.
This repeats a pattern in which defeated Iraq security forces have, over the past year, left behind US-supplied military equipment, prompting the US to destroy them in subsequent airstrikes against Islamic State forces.
Asked whether the Iraqis should have destroyed the vehicles before abandoning the city in order to keep them from enhancing IS's army, Warren said, "Certainly preferable if they had been destroyed; in this case they were not."
Warren also said that while the US is confident that Ramadi will be retaken by Iraq, "It will be difficult."
The fall of Ramadi has prompted some to question the viability of the Obama administration's approach in Iraq, which is a blend of retraining and rebuilding the Iraqi army, prodding Baghdad to reconcile with the nation's Sunnis, and bombing Islamic State targets from the air without committing American ground combat troops.
"The president's plan isn't working. It's time for him to come up with overarching strategy to defeat the ongoing terrorist threat," House Speaker John Boehner said.
White House spokesman Josh Earnest said President Barack Obama has always been open to suggestions for improving the US approach in Iraq.
"It's something that he's talking about with his national security team just about every day, including today," Earnest said.
Derek Harvey, a retired Army colonel and former Defense Intelligence Agency officer who served multiple tours in Iraq, says that while the extremist group has many problems and weaknesses, it is "not losing" in the face of ineffective Sunni Arab opposition.
"They are adaptive and they remain well armed and well resourced," Harvey said of the militants. "The different lines of operation by the US coalition remain disjointed, poorly resourced and lack an effective operational framework, in my view."
One alternative for the Obama administration would be a containment strategy -- trying to fence in the conflict rather than push the Islamic State group out of Iraq. That might include a combination of airstrikes and US special operations raids to limit the group's reach. In fact, a Delta Force raid in Syria on Friday killed an IS leader known as Abu Sayyaf who US officials said oversaw the group's oil and gas operations, a major source of funding.
Officials have said containment might become an option but is not under active discussion now.
Gen. Martin Dempsey, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, issued a written statement Monday that suggested Ramadi will trigger no change in the US approach.
"Setbacks are regrettable but not uncommon in warfare," Dempsey said. "Much effort will now be required to reclaim the city."
It seems highly unlikely that Obama would take the more dramatic route of sending ground combat forces into Iraq to rescue the situation in Ramadi or elsewhere. A White House spokesman, Eric Shultz, said Monday the US will continue its support through airstrikes, advisers and trainers.
The administration has said repeatedly that it does not believe Iraq can be stabilized for the long term unless Iraqis do the ground fighting.
Pentagon officials insisted Monday the current US approach to combating IS in Iraq is still viable and that the loss of Ramadi was merely part of the ebb and flow of war, not a sign that the Islamic State had exposed a fatal weakness in the Iraqi security forces and the US strategy.
Others are skeptical.
"We don't really have a strategy at all," former Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Tuesday on MSNBC. "We're basically playing this day by day."
Gates, who headed the Pentagon for Obama as well as President George W. Bush's administration before that, said "right now, it looks like they're (Iraq) going the way of Yugoslavia," suggesting an eventual breakup of the state.
The Institute for the Study of War, which closely tracks developments in Iraq, said Ramadi was a key Islamic State victory.
"This strategic gain constitutes a turning point in ISIS' ability to set the terms of battle in Anbar as well to project force in eastern Iraq," the institute said.
Associated Press writers Alan Fram and Nedra Pickler contributed to this report.
Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.