Is American an Empire? Is It an Evil Empire?

March 14th, 2004 - by admin

by Listener Response to BBC Series –

The Age of Empire series was broadcast on a succession of Mondays on BBC World Service Radio. Here are some of the listener responses that were mailed in:

America is an empire. But only to the extent that it can place its commercial outpost in key places. These outposts of American imperial might go by the names of McDonalds, Burger King, Pizza Hut, Starbucks among others. These outposts are everywhere (Just take a walk outside of Windsor Castle). Historically speaking, it is a pretty benign for the most part.
Jose Palacios, Miami, FL

People seem to forget the States themselves are empire. There were people living here before the Mayflower arrived, you know. It’s said that when an evil rises, other nations bond as strange bedfellows to put that evil down.
The USSR, Britain, and the USA did it to end Nazism. Maybe we’ve seen a sneak preview of another “bonding for the world’s sake” via the Russian, French, and German opposition to the American Blitz in Iraq.
I just hope the Europeans resolve holds out as the American people have failed to check our own extremist leaders.
Stan McPeek, Duluth, Minnesota

I find it interesting that the United States is actively involved in 140 countries. This was stated a while ago on a newscast I had been casually listening to about the CIA.
More importantly, I thought that might not be a good idea until I heard the US being beat up about our failure to provide support to Afghanistan after the Russians left. Now, wait a minute. We are cursed for our interference around the world, but now, we are cursed for not entering another country? So, if we are damned both ways by world opinion, maybe it is better to just go it our way?
John Hastie, Darlington, WI USA

Bravo to Mr. Marcus and his very even-handed approach to a long unasked question.
In my opinion, the American people aren’t very informed regarding the actions of their government. Benjamin Franklin once said “We have simple solutions, what we need are simple problems,” and I think those words still ring true today.
America is a massive, complex entity which can no longer live in the vacuum George Washington once prescribed. Like it or not, we can’t hide behind the two oceans on our borders forever.
The American people need to get away from the idea that more money, more technology, and less oversight will solve their problems.
I guess what’s most astounding to me is the unshakable faith some Americans continue to have in their government after so many miscues, from the Bay of Pigs to the War in Iraq. It’s this naive, self-blinding approach which hurts America more than any other single force.
If America really is a superpower, and if it really is an Empire, it will almost certainly crumble from within, not without.
Dan Weber, Boston, Massachusetts, USA

I think more attention needs to be paid to the economic underpinnings of imperial ambitions. They say the British Empire was acquired in “a fit of absence of mind”, mainly by businesses like The East India Company and the Hudson’s Bay Company. Is this not also true of the United States? And having become economically dependent on a commanding position in world trade, is the development of a giant military to defend that position not inevitable?
But the costs of defending an ever-expanding Empire always outweigh the benefits in the long run — witness the present American balance of trade and currency troubles. Not too different from the British, and for the same reasons.
Didn’t the Vietnam War kill the US gold standard, the height of the Cold War cause the 1985 dollar devaluation, and the Gulf Wars cause the current devaluation? Just like the Brits going into debt in the World Wars, eh?
Paul Connor, Toronto, Canada

Empires have existed for nearly all of human history, and there’s no reason to think that the US is somehow immune to this tendency. If we are to be an empire, let’s have it be an empire that does more than what is good for us and us alone in the short term.
We need to pay more, not less, attention to the rest of the world, and grant other peoples the respect we want to receive. That’s the way to distinguish this empire. Denial is just denial.
Kate, NYC

The United States is an empire. Like the Roman Empire, the US expanded and expanded, gobbling up its neighbours until it reached a sort of geographic equilibrium between centrifugal and centrifugal tendencies. Then, like Rome, it sought to dominate other nations through a system of treaties and economic domination.
And the Romans were happy with this arrangement, until one of their clients, or allies, or any weaker nation in general, got too uppity, and then it was smashed down, much in the same way the US has done to the third world, especially Latin America. So yes, the US is definitely an empire, by any definition. And I think this Bush neo-Conservative doctrine merely confirms this.
However, the average American is not particularly interested in empire; all s/he wants is for the prospect of a better life for him/her and his/her children.
Americans better wake up and make a choice; if you want empire and it’s benefits, then you have to be willing to go along with the empire-sized problems that come with; if not, then Americans need to undergo a radical change in lifestyle and attitude.
We want our cake and to eat it too, but in the long run life doesn’t work that way.
Bennett, Los Angeles

America an Empire!?! The perspective that the world views America as an Empire is very ironic. Americans as a whole have no interest in ruling other lands. We’re more concerned with our own lives then the rest of world (whether right or wrong).
The Globe however tends to criticize the US then holds out their needy hands whenever a conflict arises. The world at every conflict looks to the US for help. I think a good story might be how the US got nominated as a scapegoat by the rest of their Global neighbors.
It might be interesting if the US ever turned their back and said ‘fend for yourself’. By the way how far in left field are Californians from the rest of the US?
JS, Ohio, USA

As America controls more resources than any other country on the planet it is necessarily an imperial power. How it chooses to exercise that power is another question.
Presently there is a malign administration at the wheel with thinly disguised ambitions to control Middle East energy resources and to eliminate any resistance thereof.
In support, the US imperial lords have an isolated, uninformed and bovine electorate to support hysterical ravings regarding ‘freedom and democracy’.
Imperial ambitions are only viable in the US political process under this arrangement. Once elected the emperor can do what he wants.
Robert Taylor, Pasadena, California USA

The US is probably the most benign empire in history, due to its people’s reluctance to pursue an imperial policy. The US holds a significant economical and military power, which today has a global reach. This power has been rising since the end of the Civil War: the US has taken advantage of its huge natural resources, its solid social and political system, the geographical isolation and thus the absence of competing neighbours and finally over 130 years without a war fought on its territory.
Inevitably, the US interests make “imperial decisions” at times, and its power makes them possible, in order to protect the security and standard of living of its citizens. But these “imperial decisions” do not amount to a classic empire. In fact, they are strongly restrained by a culture reluctant to dominate and exploit.
Thus, the US governments had to justify any “imperial decision” through higher ideals, and prove them by a great deal of sharing with other nations.
Michael Cortelletti, Ithaca, NY USA & Berlin, Germany

Certainly the US is an empire. Yes we have the elements of a militaristic empire. However the strength lies in our true empire, an economic one. I don’t know that we ever set out to become an empire, rather I would say the world asked us to.
Kevin Norsen, Buffalo, New York

Somebody is going to be King of the Hill, better the Americans than the Chinese or the Germans, for lord’s sake.
I was personally involved in American politics, and yes I wanted power, not so I could rub someone else’s face in it, but to keep them from rubbing mine!
Say what you will but it can be a whole lot worse. An American will kick the devil out of you but buy you a beer afterwards.
Reed Schrichte, Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam

I think it’s time we Americans admit we are imperialists. What else is it called when you litter the globe with military bases, thus bringing every nation on the planet within your military reach? Now that’s influence.
I’m thankful for this article, as maybe Americans might become more honest with themselves when they talk foreign policy. Then hopefully we can do something to change it.
Dan Bluemel, Hollywood, California, USA

Empire? No not really, we dominate in the economic sphere, because we have created a competitive system. This was necessary because of the vast physical size of the USA, which has given rise to literally hundreds of key industries.
Most countries are small and do not have much real competition. Usually, small countries have only a few key players or industries which control everything.
America has no desire to physically dominate others or occupy another country long term. Our nation is one of immigrants and they came here to get away from that.
Mark Seiler, Harrison, Ohio

Empire yes, what do we think we are when we run around (and have since our inception) the world influencing the political systems of other countries for the good of American Corporations? The good guys?
I suspect it is hard for people who have never read about history outside of a public school, to fully understand what we are. We are an Empire whether we like it or not, and I suggest if you feel uncomfortable with the term do something about it, read something other than the news fed to us by big business, and vote, and be vocal.
Elizabeth Bernard, Greenfield, America

Bravo for really trying to understand what makes Americans tick and not some knee-jerk reactionary pre-drawn conclusion statements.
Ok, with that said, the US has an identity of not even wanting to deal with the rest of the world. All of the people here came to get away from the mess “over there”. We have a national collective desire to be “left alone” to raise our kids and live our lives in peace. However, when someone threatens that peace, we will destroy the threat.
We are also a land of fighters and winners. Once you get the national will behind a cause, there is NO nation on earth that can stop us. We didn’t start this war, but “WE will finish it!”
As for empire? Only because Europe embraces socialism, has it been left behind. Look seriously at the other world players. The only three countries in the world that have a chance to be our equal are UK, India and China. The rest are either corrupt, socialist or just now beginning to industrialize.
Craig Traylor, Houston, Texas

Sorry Doug, but the US population has supported imperial ambitions for the past, oh, 200 years, I think. The US is a nation very much at home with conquest and dominance, beginning, first, with the westward “expansion” and continuing to this day through various episodes such as the Spanish-American War, World Wars I and II (which made the US a power on the European continent by setting us up in the vacuum left by Germany’s defeat), and the Persian Gulf Wars (giving us imperial control over an enormous oil reserve).
The US population does, indeed, support “all” such imperial ventures; however, it supports them in a state of almost pathetic denial whereby it believes it is supporting good and noble efforts (“the war to end all wars”, etc.) while, in fact, it is, in reality, being misled and duped.
Chris Edmonds, Walnut Creek, California

Anyone who believes the US population would support long-term Imperial ambitions has little understanding of Americans. The vast bulk of us carry family histories replete with suffering from Imperialistic expansions of others in Europe, Asia, and elsewhere. Empire USA?
No way, except perhaps in the case of the moon.
Doug Petersen, Twin Falls, Idaho USA