General Claims Call for Democracy Caused His Dismissal

March 22nd, 2004 - by admin

David Leigh / The Guardian (UK) – 2004-03-22 11:00:38

LONDON (March 18, 2004) — Jay Garner, the US general abruptly dismissed as Iraq’s first occupation administrator after a month in the job, says he fell out with the Bush circle after he called for swift and free elections and rejected an imposed programme of privatisation.

In an interview to be broadcast on BBC Newsnight, Friday, March 19, he says: “My preference was to put the Iraqis in charge as soon as we can, and do it with some form of elections … I just thought it was necessary to rapidly get the Iraqis in charge of their destiny.”

[The BBC program will air at 10:30 GMT; it will also be available at 7:30 PM EST on the internet at]

Asked by the reporter Greg Palast if he foresaw negative repercussions from the subsequent US imposition of mass privatisation , Gen Garner said: “I don’t know … we’ll just have to wait and see.” It would have been better for the Iraqis to take decisions themselves, even if they made mistakes, he said.

“What I was trying to do was get to a functioning government … We as Americans like to put our template on things. And our template’s good, but it’s not necessarily good for everyone else.”

Describing his dismissal after he called for elections , he said: “The night I got to Baghdad, [the defence secretary Donald] Rumsfeld called me and told me he was appointing Paul Bremer as the presidential envoy … The announcement … was somewhat abrupt.”

Gen Garner was careful not to criticise his successor directly. He said the imposition before elections of free market economic schemes drawn up by the US as early as 2001 “was a more orderly approach” than his own.

But he had wanted the Iraqis to decide economic policy for themselves. “They’ll make mistakes, and that’s OK … I don’t think they need to go by the US plan.”

Despite being a protege of Mr Rumsfeld, Gen Garner was the subject of what was alleged to be a White House whispering campaign, describing him as weak.

A year after the invasion, his disclosure of policy differences with the White House highlights the dilemma still faced by the US occupation forces.

Greg Palast is author of the New York Times bestseller, The Best Democracy Money Can Buy.Harper’s, The Guardian (UK) and BBC television at