US Officials Reject AI Report on Abuse

May 30th, 2005 - by admin

BBC / Fox News / Philadelphia Inquirer – 2005-05-30 22:55:09

US General Rejects Amnesty Report
BBC News Online

(May 30, 2005) — The human rights group last week described the US detention camp in Cuba as “the gulag of our time”. But US Gen Richard Myers said the US military treated detainees there humanely.

The Guantanamo Bay camp has been the focus of protests in the Muslim world, after allegations that guards had been disrespectful towards the Koran.

Speaking on the US television network Fox News, Gen Myers said the camp was “essentially a model facility”. He said 1,300 Korans had been handed out to detainees in 13 different languages and that prison staff had served up “the proper Muslim-approved food”.

“I think I’d ask them to go look up the definition of gulag as commonly understood,” he said of Amnesty’s report.

Guantanamo Bay has received much attention recently as the result of a Newsweek report this month which said US guards had flushed a Koran down a toilet.

Newsweek has retracted its story, which sparked violent anti-US protests in Afghanistan, as well as demonstrations in Pakistan and Indonesia. However, the US military has admitted to five incidents in which the Koran was mishandled by staff at the camp.

Gen Myers said the prisoners at Guantanamo were dangerous and the US was doing its best. “How do you handle people who… who aren’t part of a nation-state effort, that are picked up on the battlefield… that if you release them, or if you let them go back to their home countries, that would turn right around and try to slit our throats, our children’s throats?” he said. “The president said we’ll treat people humanely and in accordance with the Geneva Convention. We’re doing that.”

He said the International Committee of the Red Cross had had access to Guantanamo “from the day we opened the gates. I mean essentially, they’ve (ICRC) been there the whole time. And we get good marks for the way we take care of people,” he added.

Cheney Offended by Gitmo Criticism
Fox News

WASHINGTON (May 30, 2005) — Vice President Dick Cheney says he’s offended by a human rights group’s report criticizing conditions at the prison camp for terror suspects at Guantanamo Bay.

The report Amnesty International released last week said prisoners at the US Navy base in Cuba had been mistreated and called for the prison to be shut down. Cheney derided the London-based group in an interview set to be broadcast Monday night on “Larry King Live.”

“Frankly, I was offended by it,” Cheney said in the videotaped interview. “For Amnesty International to suggest that somehow the United States is a violator of human rights, I frankly just don’t take them seriously.” Cheney is the latest Bush administration official to object to the report. On Sunday, Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Gen. Richard Myers called the Amnesty International report “absolutely irresponsible.”

Washington’s defense of its detention and interrogation practices comes after weeks of international criticism and violent protests by Muslims outraged at reports — which the Pentagon says are false — that an interrogator at Guantanamo had flushed pages of the Quran down a toilet.

Cheney said detainees at Guantanamo “have been well treated, treated humanely and decently….. Occasionally there are allegations of mistreatment,” Cheney said. “But if you trace those back, in nearly every case, it turns out to come from somebody who had been inside and released to their home country and now are peddling lies about how they were treated.”

Some of the scores of prisoners who have been released from Guantanamo have said they were mistreated, while others have said they were not. Other allegations have surfaced in FBI reports and transcripts of review hearings the military held for the prisoners.

Pentagon officials say they have substantiated five cases where copies of the Quran, the Muslim holy book, were mistreated, although the military has refused to offer details other than to say none was ever flushed down a toilet.

© Associated Press. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 2005 ComStock, Inc.
Copyright 2005 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved

Posted in accordance with Section 107, Title 17, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.

Rice Rejects Calls for Inquiry into
Guantanamo Prison Abuse

Warren P. Strobel / Inquirer

SAN FRANCISCO (May 29, 2005) — Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, in an interview, brushed off growing calls for an independent investigation of conditions at the Guantanamo Bay detention center and labeled as “absurd” a new Amnesty International report equating the facility with Soviet-era gulags.

She said an outside investigation of the facility at the U.S. naval base in Cuba was not necessary.

“The United States is as open a society as you will find,” she said, and the administration is being held accountable “by a free press, by a Congress that is a separate and coequal branch of government, and by its own expectations of what is right.”

Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, a close Bush ally, last week demanded an investigation of allegations that U.S. interrogators abused the Koran, the Muslim holy book, at Guantanamo Bay. The Pentagon is investigating five instances when the Koran may have been mishandled, but officials say they have found no evidence to support the incendiary charge that U.S. personnel flushed the holy book down a toilet.

Another U.S. ally, Afghan President Hamid Karzai, expressed anger over new reports of how detainees had died while American forces were interrogating them in Afghanistan.

Amnesty’s report also said that despite “near-universal outrage” over treatment of detainees, “neither the U.S. administration nor the U.S. Congress has called for a full and independent investigation.”

Rice, a Soviet scholar by training, seemed particularly indignant at Amnesty’s characterization of Guantanamo Bay as “the gulag of our times,” an allusion to Soviet prison camps under Joseph Stalin.

While the human-rights group has done important work around the world, “this is unfortunate and sad,” she said. At another point in the interview, she said: “I think it’s absurd language.”

“The United States of America is one of the strongest defenders of human rights around the world. We’ve fought hard and worked hard even in the circumstances of a new kind of war [on terrorism] to treat people humanely,” Rice said.

While acknowledging that “sometimes bad things happen,” Rice argued that the charges of Koran abuse and other violations should be put in context.

American personnel at Guantanamo Bay have shown great respect for detainees’ religion, for example providing them with prayer mats and arrows pointing to Mecca, the direction that Muslims turn to pray, she said.

She also expressed concern that American forces would be tarred unfairly by the actions of a few.

“A lot of the men and women in uniform, who people sometimes by association look at in the context of [abuses at the Iraqi prison] Abu Ghraib, have liberated 50 million people by their own blood and sacrifice over the last 31/2 years,” she said.

Rice spoke late Thursday as she flew across the country from Washington in a small jet to take a rare vacation in California.

She gave a speech Friday in San Francisco at the Commonwealth Club of California, outlining Bush’s second-term campaign to expand democracy around the world.

She was interrupted when two audience members, clad in black hoods and capes reminiscent of the photographs of detainees at Abu Ghraib, stood in silent protest. They and two others were thrown out of San Francisco’s Davies Symphony Hall, chanting, “Stop the torture. Stop the killing. U.S. out of Iraq.”

Rice attempted to turn the interruption to her advantage. Freedom is coming to Iraq, Afghanistan, Lebanon, and other Muslim societies, she said, and the audience applauded.

“They, too, will be able to speak their minds,” Rice said. “What a wonderful thing democracy is.”

In the interview, Rice, who had just come from Bush’s White House meeting with Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas, indicated that she was intensely focused on Israel’s planned withdrawal from the Gaza Strip.

The withdrawal is a huge opportunity for the Palestinians to begin building their own state, the secretary of state said. But she also expressed worry about how much Abbas and others had to accomplish before the scheduled beginning of Israel’s disengagement in August.

“When we talk about a successful withdrawal from Gaza, we obviously mean that the Israelis are able to leave in conditions that are peaceful,” she said. “But we also mean that the Palestinians are left with governing structures… that then become the foundation for a broader Palestinian state.

“It’s a lot to try and do in several months, but everybody seems very dedicated.”

© 2005 Philadelphia Inquirer and wire service sources. All Rights Reserved.

Posted in accordance with Title 17, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposs.