Russia Fires Warning Shots at HMS Defender in Black Sea
Ilya Tsukanov / Sputnik
(June 23, 2021) — Earlier in the day, Moscow urged the United States and its NATO allies to stop military operations in the Black Sea region, calling instead for “multilateral efforts” aimed at maintaining stability, and for states in the region to resolve problems without unwanted “help” from outside powers.
A Russian warship has fired warning shots after the HMS Defender, a British Royal Navy destroyer, violated Russia’s maritime borders in the Black Sea, the Russian Ministry of Defence announced Wednesday.
Along with the naval manoeuvres, a Russian Su-24M attack aircraft carried out a mock bombing run against the British warship, according to the ministry.
“At 11:52 am on 23 June, the HMS Defender of the British Royal Navy, operating in the northwestern part of the Black Sea, violated the border and entered three kilometres into Russian territorial waters in the region of Cape Fiolent,” the MoD said in a press statement.
According to the military, the British warship was warned that deadly force would be used if it violated Russia’s borders. The ship was said to have ignored the warning.
“At 12:06 and 12:08, a border patrol vessel carried out warning shots. At 12:19 a Su-24M carried out a warning bombing run using 4 OFAB-250 [high-explosive fragmentation] bombs at the HMS Defender‘s path of movement,” the statement added. “At 12:23 the combined actions of the Black Sea Fleet and the Border Forces of the FSB forced the HMS Defender to leave the territorial waters of the Russian Federation.”
UK Denies Incident Took Place, Denies Warning Shots Were Fired
The UK Defence Ministry commented on the incident on Wednesday afternoon, denying that any warning shots were fired, and saying its warship was conducting an “innocent passage through Ukrainian territorial waters in accordance with international law.”
“We believe the Russians were undertaking a gunnery exercise in the Black Sea and provided the maritime community with prior-warning of their activity. No shots were directed at HMS Defender and we do not recognize the claim that bombs were dropped in her path,” the ministry said in a pair of tweets.
Defence Minister Ben Wallace similarly indicated that the British warship was carrying out “a routine transit” from Odessa towards Georgia, and suggested that the ship was operating in an “internationally recognised traffic separation corridor,” “safely” exiting it at 9:45 am British standard time while being shadowed by Russian ships. Wallace echoed the Defence Ministry’s claims that the British ship was informed of Russian “training exercises in her wider vicinity.”
The Russian Defence Ministry issued another statement later in the day, saying Moscow regards the HMS Defender‘s actions as a gross violation of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, reiterating that the ship had been warned about the possible use of force, and demanding a “thorough investigation” into the incident.
In its own statement, the Russian Foreign Ministry said it characterizes the British warship’s actions as a “gross provocation,” and that the British Ambassador to Russia would be summoned in connection with the incident. The Russian Defence Ministry has also summoned the attaché on defence matters from the British Embassy in Moscow.
The HMS Defender‘s automatic identification system (AIS) signal showed the ship to be situated about 40 km off Crimea as of 14:15 local time Wednesday, and to be sailing southeast.
AIS signal showing deployment of UK warship off Crimea’s coast.
The Russian military began tracking the HMS Defender and the Royal Netherlands Navy’s HNLMS Evertsen frigate on 14 June after the pair of NATO warships entered the Black Sea. Earlier this month, the MoD indicated that it would be closely watching NATO’s annual ‘Sea Breeze’ drills, involving Ukrainian and alliance forces, including 4,000 servicemen, 40 warships, and 30 aircraft, once they kick off on 28 June.
Earlier this week, open-source intelligence analyst H. I. Sutton reported that the HMS Defender and the HNLMS Evertsen‘s AIS signals showed the ships to have ‘travelled’ from Odessa to within two nautical miles of Sevastopol harbour — the highly sensitive military port home to the Russian Black Sea Fleet.
The apparent spoofing attack was later proven to be a hoax, although it’s not clear who was behind it. The Russian military closely monitors any and all movement by NATO warships in the Black Sea, and has the technical means to watch all alliance activity in the body of water.
The Russian military regularly reports on attempts by NATO aircraft and drones to test the country’s maritime frontiers and airspace in the sensitive region, with Russian aircraft scrambled whenever a foreign power’s military equipment comes too close to the border. The MoD has reported on thousands of maritime and aerial reconnaissance incidents along Russia’s borders in the Arctic, the Baltic and Black Seas and the Russian Far East in recent years, with bloc spying operations complimented by regular NATO and US drills and troop deployments near Russia’s borders.
The Defence Ministry has concentrated special attention to ensuring the security of Crimea, with pro-Western authorities in Kiev and NATO nations refusing to recognise Russian jurisdiction over the peninsula, notwithstanding a popular referendum which saw the overwhelming majority of the territory’s residents vote to break off from Ukraine and rejoin Russia in early 2014 in the aftermath of the Maidan coup.
Ukrainian authorities have recently stepped up diplomatic pressure on the United States to allow the Eastern European country to join NATO, with President Volodymyr Zelensky demanding a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer from Joe Biden on the matter, and Kiev’s ambassador to Germany warning recently that Ukraine may build nuclear weapons if it is refused entry.
Black Ops in the Black Sea
A former British ambassador reacts to news that Russia
fired warning shots at a UK destroyer inside Crimea’s territorial waters
(June 23, 2021) — Sometimes it is worth stating the obvious. The United Kingdom does not have a coast in the Black Sea. British warships are not infesting the Black Sea out of a peaceful intent, and there is no cause for them to be entering disputed waters close to anybody’s coast.
This is not a question of freedom of navigation under the UN Convention of the Law of the Sea. There is nowhere that a British warship can be heading from the UK under the right of innocent passage that would require it to pass through coastal waters by Crimea. The Black Sea is famously a cul-de-sac.
I expect we will now be in for a mad frenzy of Russophobia, yet again. I shall comment further once I have more details of why and exactly where Russia was firing warning shots. But just remember this, it was not Russian warships near the British coast, it was British warships in an area where they had no business other than ludicrous, British nationalist, sabre-rattling.
The UK needs to lose its imperial delusions. Sending gunboats to the Crimea is as mad as — well, sailing an aircraft carrier expressly to threaten the Chinese. There are those who see this activity as evidence of the UK’s continued great power status. I see it as evidence of lunacy.
Craig Murray is an author, broadcaster and human rights activist. He was British ambassador to Uzbekistan from August 2002 to October 2004 and rector of the University of Dundee from 2007 to 2010. This article is from CraigMurray.org.uk. Subscriptions to keep his blog going are gratefully received.
Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.