Hawaii Official Calls Navy Underground Fuel Storage Facility a ‘Ticking Time Bomb’
(December 28, 2021) — A Hawaii official says that the Navy’s Red Hill underground fuel storage facility is a “ticking time bomb” as both sides grapple with the fallout of a leak that contaminated an important source of drinking water.
David Day, who has been overseeing hearings regarding operations at Red Hill, made the comment in a proposed order upholding a previous state mandate to defuel the facility, among other demands.
The Navy has until Wednesday to file any exceptions to the proposed order. A Navy spokesman told The Hill that it is aware of the proposed decision but had no further statement.
“The weight of the evidence establishes that the Red Hill Facility, as currently situated, is a metaphorical ticking time bomb located 100 feet above the most important aquifer on Hawaii’s most populous island,” Day wrote.
The Red Hill facility, which was constructed during World War II, is an underground storage system in Oahu, about 2.5 miles northeast of Pearl Harbor. The facility sits directly above a groundwater aquifer, which is the principal source of drinking water for the island.
The facility consists of 20 field-constructed underground storage tanks which can hold up to 12.7 million gallons of fuel.
In late November, the Navy reported a release of about 14,000 gallons of a mixture of fuel and water at the Red Hill facility, which caused fuel contamination of one of the military’s drinking water sources.
The Hawaii Department of Health ordered the Navy to immediately suspend operations at Red Hill, install a water treatment system at the facility, and to submit a plan to safely defuel the tanks at the facility.
The Navy has suspended operations at the facility while it conducts an investigation, but appealed the state’s order. Hearings were held on the order last week.
This isn’t the first incident at Red Hill. Day’s order pointed out that there have been at least 76 incidents from Red Hill involving 200,000 gallons of fuel over the past eight decades.
Two incidents were reported in May and July.
But the November incident caused a “humanitarian crisis and environmental emergency and disaster,” Day wrote.
“Continued operation of the Red Hill Facility, as it is currently configured and operated, poses an imminent threat to human health and safety or the environment,” he said.
Contaminated Water Puts Military Housing at Risk
Sierra Club Executive Director Wayne Tanaka
calls for Red Hill fuel tanks to be shut down.
Many Questions Remain Unanswered For Residents of Honolulu
Ann Wright / Popular Resistance.
HAWAI’I (December 27, 2921) — On Friday, December 24, I went to Aliamanu Military Reservation at Red Hill housing area which is located above the entryway into the main tunnel that leads into the US Navy’s deep, massive, leaking 80-year-old Red Hill underground jet fuel storage tanks complex. These tanks are only 100 feet above the main aquifer of drinking water for 400,000, half the population of the island of O’ahu, Hawai’i.
A recent leak of at least 19,000 gallons of jet fuel and water leaked from a fire suppressant pipe into two Navy operated wells that supply drinking water to over 93,000 residents in the Pearl Harbor-Hickam Air Force Base area.
Built during World War II, the tank complex has 20 huge tanks, each measuring 100 feet in diameter and 250 feet high — the height of a 20-story building, or Aloha Tower, a famous landmark for tourist ships in Honolulu harbor. Each tank can hold 12.5 million gallons of fuel. Fuel travels 2.5 miles via an extensive pipeline network to ships and planes at Pearl Harbor Naval Base and Hickam Air Force Base. The Navy says that only 18 tanks are in use and hold a total of 180 million gallons of jet fuel.
Petroleum poisoning from contaminated drinking water
occurred in military and civilian families prior to November 2021 leaks
Military families have reported that they had been suffering from the effects of water contamination for months prior to November 28, 2021 when the US Navy acknowledged that two water wells had been polluted from leaking 80-year-old massive jet fuel tanks. The Washington Post interviewed ten military families who suffered symptoms of vomiting, diarrhea and rashes earlier this year, prior to the November leaks.
Over 3,500 military families have been relocated to hotels in Waikiki as they cannot use the water in their homes. Hundreds have gone to military and civilian hospitals for treatment of symptoms caused by drinking and bathing with fuel contaminated water. Some have reported serious breathing, mental clarity and mobility issues that are lasting weeks.
Out of 20 jet fuel tanks,
eight tanks NOT inspected in 20 years
and three tanks NOT inspected in 40 years
At a December 20, 2021 contested case hearing held by the Hawai’i State Department of Health following the Navy objection to an emergency order of the Governor of the Hawai’i for the Navy to remove fuel from the tanks and halt operations at the Red Hill complex, The Navy disclosed that the May 6-7, 2021 pipeline leak that the Navy said release 1,618 gallons of fuel due to operator error that the Navy had maintained did not contaminate drinking water actually was a discharge of 19,000 gallons of jet fuel.
At the hearing the Department of Health emphasized that 8 of the massive fuel tanks had not been inspected in 20 years and four had not been inspected in 40 years!
Map of areas to which the US Navy provides water from its wells that drill into the aquifer that provides water for 400,000 residents of Honolulu.
To enlarge map view, go to map here
Does putting untreated petroleum products into
Navy and Honolulu city sewage systems decontaminate the water?
Photo by Ann Wright of Water Hydrant #1 flushing contaminated petroleum water into sewage line at AMR-Red Hill.
There are two flushing stations in operation at Aliamanu Military Reservation (mauka side). One of the flushing stations is at the highest point in the housing area and the second about 3 blocks lower. I spoke with a US Army civilian who was supervising the flushing and who was showing a Hawai’i State Department of Health visitor around the flushing site. I didn’t want to appear too inquisitive so I didn’t ask for the name of either person.
Photo by Ann Wright of Water Hydrant #2 flushing contaminated petroleum water into sewage line at AMR-Red Hill
Each flushing point has several active duty Army soldiers watching the equipment. One fire hydrant in each location was hooked up by a hose that directed water from the fire hydrant into the sewage system. One of the flushing stations is at the highest point in the and the second about 3 blocks lower.
The Department of the Army civilian wanted to make the distinction that although he didn’t know which sewage system the contaminated water was being flushed into and whether the sewage systems had the capability to clean the water, at least the contaminated water was not going into the storm drains which take the untreated contaminated water directly into adjacent streams and into the ocean without any treatment.
Photo by Ann Wright of blue filtration units at AMR-Red Hill that were not being used.
There were two large blue filtration units “Carbon Supply Inc.” that were not being used on December 24. The Army civilian said they have been flushing the system for 4 days without using the filtration tanks and he didn’t know when the tanks were to be used.
He said that flushing will continue until the main water system is flushed to the satisfaction of Navy authorities.
Flushing Household pipes and refrigerators,
ice machines and washing machines will be a huge problem
At that point, they will begin going house to house to flush household water systems. He said that household flushing will be a bigger challenge as the houses have poly-ethelene plastic pipes which allows petroleum products to attach to them.
He said that the Purdue University specialists who are advising the Navy said that to clear this type of plastic of attached petroleum, the pipes would have to have clean water put into the pipes and let the water stand for a period of time to let the petroleum molecules detach from the pipes. They would then push that water out and put more clean water into the pipes, letting it stand and flushing again. He estimated it would take 5-10 flushings to get the petroleum molecules to detach.
He also said that the poly-ethelene tubes in refrigerators, ice makers and washing machines would probably have to be replaced as it would be too difficult to flush them.
A December 14, 2021 Civil Beat article stated: “Navy officials said one option being considered is flushing the contaminants into the sewage system, which they said “has the capability of handling those kinds of waste”. Lt. Cmdr. John Daly told Civil Beat that “The sewer system has some capacity for handling that additional volume that we expect to deal with, but there may be some options that are more appropriate.”
According to Navy officials, the City and County of Honolulu handles a portion of the sewage system from Red Hill, Aliamanu Military Reservation and the eastern housing community. The Honolulu Board of Water Supply didn’t respond to a request for comment, according to the Civil Beat article.
Hawaii News Now reported on December 19, 2021: The Navy said the filtration system will first be used to scrub its water distribution system and its large holding tanks. The treated water — which the Navy says will be free of chemical pollutants — will be released onto wide grassy areas, the sewer system and into select storm drains — under agreements reached with the state, the City and County of Honolulu and the EPA.
The Navy said it will next flush the water from the faucets and appliances in contaminated homes. The flushing will be conducted in a neighborhood by neighborhood in a process that will take 30 to 45 days, the Navy said.
Flushing began on December 20 in the Pearl City Peninsula military housing, Red Hill and Aliamanu Military Reservation housing.
According to the Hawai’i News Now report, the Honolulu Board of Water Supply said it was “skeptical that the Navy can scrub all of its pipes and water lines of the fuel because petroleum doesn’t dissolve in water and tends to stick to the pipes.” But the Navy said it is confident its plan will work. “We got some experience to lean on that demonstrates that this can be done through flushing,” said Lt Commander Daly.
On December 26, I went to Hickam Air Force Base and saw 13 carbon filtration units in the cargo area of the airport. Within a half-mile from the front gate, two carbon filtration units were in action. Six employees from the Michigan corporation “Clean Harbor” told me that their company had purchased quickly all the carbon filtration units needed for the contract they now have with the Defense Logistics Agency for the clean up on the water contamination.
Photo by Ann Wright of filtration unit pumping water into storm drain.
One unit was pumping water from a fire hydrant, pushing the water through two carbon units and then into a storm drain.
The second unit was pumping the water from a hydrant through two units and then out into an open field. None of the crews watching each set of equipment had seen the test results that would verify whether petroleum products had been removed from the water!!!
The Navy said the approximately 25 million gallons of water must be pushed through the filtration systems. The Navy has not said how many gallons of clean water must be used to keep cleaning the pipes from residual petroleum stuck on the pipes.
Map of Areas with petroleum contaminated water and schedule for attempts of flushing the water systems.
Map is available at: https://www.cpf.navy.mil/Portals/52/Flushing-Plan-Graphic-V6-19DEC21.pdf
The citizens of O’ahu are demanding answers to the following questions, among many, concerning the flushing of the petroleum contaminated from Navy water systems are:
- After contaminated water is put through the Navy mobile filtration systems, how many petroleum products are still registering in the “filtered” water?
- How much “filtered” water was discharged onto ground at Pearl City peninsula?
- How much unfiltered water from the Red Hill military community main water system has been put into the sewage system?
- Which sewage system was the Red Hill main water system drained into?
- How does that sewage system “treat” petroleum contaminated water?
- What are the results of testing from that sewage system?
- How many other flushing sites are putting untreated contaminated water into sewage systems?
- Which sewage systems has untreated contaminated water been put into and how much water was put into each?
- Has each sewage system been tested?
- Has any water put through mobile filtration systems been put into storm drains rather than sewage systems.
- If so, now much and where are the outfalls into the ocean of each storm drainage system?
- Has each storm drainage outfall been tested after mobile filtered water has been released into the drainage system?
But the answers to the two most important questions for the residents of O’ahu are:
- When will the US Navy drain the leaking 80-year-old Red Hill jet fuel storage tanks?
- When will the US Department of Defense announce the PERMANENT Shut Down of the Red Hill jet fuel tanks?
Ann Wright is a retired US Army/Army Reserve Colonel and a former US diplomat. She resigned from the US government in March 2003 in opposition to the US war on Iraq. She is a member of Veterans For Peace, CODEPINK: Women for Peace and Hawai’i Peace and Justice. She has lived in Honolulu, Hawai’i for 20 years. She is the co-author of Dissent: Voices of Conscience.
Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, US Code, for noncommercial, educational purposes.