A Chicago Tribune Letter-writer Gets a
History Lesson on US-Iran Relations
Walt Zlotow / West Suburban Peace Coalition
(October 26, 2026) — At 79, Chicago Tribune letter writer Mike Noonan is not too old to get a history lesson on US Iran relations. His letter ‘Unconditional surrender’ laments Trump is not fighting his clearly lost Iran war to the death.
“The stated goal of Iran and its proxies is death to the United States…especially if it develops a nuclear weapon. We must win the war with Iran and its proxies. Unconditional surrender, not a negotiated settlement, is needed now….. because their unwillingness to negotiate in good faith (both now and in the last 40 years).”
Astonishingly, Noonan wants US troops sent to finish Trump’s Mission Impossible.
Somehow, Mike Noonan missed that it was President Trump who was repeatedly threatening to wipe out the entire Iranian civilization; indeed, even before the United Nations General Assembly. It was Trump who sucker-punched Iran with bombs while negotiating peace in June 2025, and again in all out war on February 28 this year. After twice being deceived with bombs, Iran fought back ferociously, essentially defeating the most murderous, duplicitous regime on earth.
In truth, it’s America that has been at war with Iran for decades and a lot longer than 47 years. One must go back 73 years to Operation Ajax, America’s first Iran regime change operation, which toppled the legitimate Iranian Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh in 1953 to retain British, US control of Iranian oil. Once deposed, the US installed Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the Shah of Iran, to serve US interests in perpetuity. For the Iranian people it meant the Shah’s brutal rule enabled by the US military and CIA which killed upwards of 10,000 anti Shah dissidents.
After twenty-six years the Iranian people forced the Shah to flee in February 1979, allowing the transition from monarchy to an Islamic Republic.
Had President Carter not allowed America’s three decade puppet ruler to seek refuge in the US, there likely never would have been the November 4, 1979 takeover of the US embassy by 500 students resulting in taking 66 US hostages for 444 days.
Shortly thereafter the new Iranian government made 3 reasonable demands of the US, that if granted, would likely have promptly returned the hostages. Most important was return of the Shah, a mass murderer, to face justice in Iran. Second, a US apology for the ’53 US coup that overturned Mosaddegh and installed the Shah’s brutal rule. Third, return of the $20 billion the Shah stole and the US seized after the revolution.
Besides quick return of the 66 hostages, there would have been no failed April 1980 rescue mission that killed 8 US service members.
But the hard liners in the Carter administration led by National Security Adviser, Zbigniew Brzezinski would have none of that, setting off 47 years of endless US machinations in behest of every US administration and Israel to complete the second Iranian regime change in 73 years.
No, Iran has never attacked the US or been at war with the US…until President Trump assassinated their leader and bombed an Iranian school, killing over a hundred little girls on the first day of his deranged, criminal war to depose the Iranian regime at the behest of Israel.
Instead of diplomacy, common sense, peace, Trump gives us war, death, economic decline, possible global economic collapse. And he justifies this madness with the fantasy that the victim has been the aggressor for 47 years.
Mike Noonan, every Chicago Tribune reader; Indeed, every American needs to know this.
Walt Zlotow, West Suburban Peace Coalition Glen Ellyn IL